Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links go to other retailers and may also earn us a commission. Full disclosure.
Should a family buy a new Model Y L or a used Model X?
Tesla ended Model X production in May 2026, so the real three-row choice is now a new Model Y L (from $61,990) or a used Model X. A used 2022’23 Model X averages roughly $53,000 to $59,000, about the same as or less than a new L. The X gives you more cargo room behind the third row and up to seven seats. The L gives you a brand-new car with a full warranty, a newer interior and second-row captain’s chairs.
Model Y L floor mats are back: 3W’s custom set for the six-seater, all three rows with cargo and frunk trays in the full set, is available again on pre-order. 3W shows the current ship estimate on its product page. Our readers get 35% off direct with code PLUGIN35. See the mats and fit notes →
We earn a commission on orders that use this code, at no cost to you.
Side by side
| New Model Y L | Used Model X | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $61,990 (Premium), plus fees | About $53,000 (2022), $59,000 (2023), $69,000 (2024) on average |
| Seats | 6 (2-2-2, captain’s chairs) | 5, 6 or 7 depending on how it was built |
| Cargo behind the last row | About 15 cu ft | About 21 cu ft |
| Warranty | Full new-car coverage | Whatever remains from the original sale |
| Still being built? | Yes | No, production ended May 2026 |
Used Model X prices are October 2026 averages from CarGurus; prices vary a lot with mileage, trim and region. Model Y L pricing from Tesla.
Where the used Model X wins
- Space. More room behind the third row, which matters for strollers and road-trip luggage with every seat filled.
- Seven seats. Some Model X configurations seat seven; the Model Y L tops out at six.
- Price for the size. A 2022 or 2023 Model X costs about the same as a new L, for a bigger car.
Where the new Model Y L wins
- A new car’s warranty. A used Model X may be near the end of its basic coverage, and repairs on a larger luxury SUV aren’t cheap.
- Newer interior and tech. The L has the current Model Y design, including the rear screen for the back seat.
- Captain’s chairs. A walkway to the third row makes life easier with car seats in the second row.
- Long-term support. Tesla says it will keep servicing the Model X, but the Model Y L is a current car with years of parts and updates ahead.
What to check on a used Model X
- Battery health. Ask what range it shows at a full charge and compare it with the original EPA rating.
- Warranty left. Check the original delivery date and mileage against Tesla’s warranty terms.
- The Falcon Wing doors. Open and close them several times and check the seals and sensors.
- Seat layout. Confirm whether it’s a five-, six- or seven-seater before you fall for it.
- Service history. Tesla service records are easy to request and worth reading.
Which one we’d pick
For most families, the new Model Y L: similar money, a full warranty and a layout that’s easier with car seats. The used Model X makes sense if you need the extra cargo room or a seventh seat, and you’re comfortable buying a used luxury SUV with a careful inspection.
More: our Model Y L guide for families, which Tesla seats seven and Model Y L trunk space.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Tesla Model X discontinued?
Yes. Tesla ended Model X production in May 2026. You can still buy used ones and, in some places, a few remaining inventory cars.
Is a used Model X cheaper than a new Model Y L?
Often, yes. In October 2026, used 2022 and 2023 Model X cars averaged roughly $53,000 to $59,000, compared with $61,990 for a new Model Y L.
Which has more room, the Model Y L or Model X?
The Model X has more cargo space behind the third row and can seat up to seven. The Model Y L seats six with captain’s chairs in the second row.



