Short answer: after installing the full set, we’re glad we switched. The 3W mats fit our 2026 Model Y tighter than the Tesla mats they replaced, the removable carpet inserts look better than bare rubber, and the set is built for family messes: kids’ dirty feet in the second row, plus muddy cleats, sandy beach toys and wet sports bags in the trunk. Install took a few minutes.
Buy direct from 3W (code PLUGIN35, 35% off) →See this set on Amazon
Black Friday at 3W: 3W is running 30% off sitewide through December 3, but our reader code PLUGIN35 still takes 35% off sitewide, so use the code for the bigger discount. (It’s our affiliate code; we earn a small commission when you use it.)
What we bought
The 3W 9+3 set for the 2025–2027 Model Y, ordered from 3wliners.com with code PLUGIN35. We ordered on a Wednesday, it shipped FedEx, and it was on our doorstep by Friday. The code took over $100 off the list price, and the full set cost us far less than what we’d paid Tesla.
For comparison, the Tesla all-weather liners we’d bought before cost us $240 plus tax for the front and rear, and Tesla’s trunk mat with its seatback liners (which cover the backs of the second-row seats on the trunk side) another $220 plus tax. That’s about $460 for fewer pieces, with no frunk or sub-trunk liner and no carpet option.
The “9+3” is twelve pieces: two front floor trays, a one-piece second-row mat, three removable carpet inserts that sit inside the front and rear trays, a trunk mat, a frunk liner, a sub-trunk liner, and three seatback protectors. Everything arrived individually bagged in one flat box.

We went with the carpet-insert version instead of the all-rubber set on purpose. It looks closer to a factory interior, and the inserts lift out, so the rubber tray underneath keeps protecting the floor on a muddy or snowy day without swapping mats.

Before and after: our Tesla mats vs 3W
We’d bought Tesla’s all-weather liners for the car. They’re fine, but they’re firmer, they don’t extend under the seats the way the 3W trays do, and dust shows on the flat rubber. Here is the same footwell with each set.





Fit, spot by spot
The 3W mats are a softer plastic than Tesla’s, and that turns out to matter: they take the shape of the floor instead of fighting it. No gaps, no sliding, no corners lifting.
Driver and passenger footwells
The raised outer edge runs along the sill, which is where slush and dripping boots end up. The front trays also have an extension that reaches under the front seat. It’s a flat tray with the same ribbed surface, and it turns into a surprisingly useful spot for an umbrella or anything else that won’t roll.


Second row
One piece across the whole rear floor, with cutouts for the front seat rails and the same carpet insert on top. The second row is where the kids’ shoes, crumbs and juice spills end up, and the full-width lip keeps it all off the car’s carpet.

Frunk
The frunk liner sits flat in the floor of the frunk with a cutout for the drain plug. We don’t keep much in the frunk day to day, so for us it’s mainly about protecting the floor when something wet or muddy does end up there.


Sub-trunk
The sub-trunk liner is a deep molded tray that drops into the well under the trunk floor. It’s the piece that makes the sub-trunk safe for wet beach gear or a cooler without worrying about the carpet underneath.

Trunk and seatbacks
The trunk mat covers the cargo floor edge to edge. The three seatback protectors cover the backs of the second-row seats, the side that faces the trunk, and wrap the corners and edges, with cutouts for the latch releases and the center pass-through. Fold the second row down and the whole load area, mat plus seatbacks, is covered end to end, which is what you want for muddy cleats, sandy beach toys and wet sports bags.




The removable carpet inserts
This is the reason we picked this set. Each insert is a cut carpet pad with a bound edge that drops into the rubber tray and locks down with the round 3W clips. Pull them out and you have an all-weather mat. Put them back and the car looks like it came with carpet. For a family car that goes to the beach in July and a snowy school lot in January, having both without buying two sets is the whole point.
For spills, the carpet piece can come out and get cleaned on its own while the rubber tray underneath wipes down.
What we don’t love (yet)
Not much so far. A few pieces had creases from the box. They flattened out right away in the car, and the remaining lines are no different from what our Tesla mats showed out of the box. There was no rubber smell at all, which surprised us. We’ll update this review after a winter of salt and slush.
3W vs the Tesla mats, in one table
| Tesla all-weather mats | 3W 9+3 set | |
|---|---|---|
| Pieces | Front, rear, trunk (frunk and sub-trunk sold separately) | 12: fronts, rear, 3 carpet inserts, trunk, frunk, sub-trunk, 3 seatback protectors |
| Material | Firm rubber | Softer TPE that molds to the floor |
| Fit | Firmer, doesn’t mold to the floor | Softer, takes the shape of the floor; no gaps or sliding |
| Carpet option | No | Yes, removable |
| Under-seat extension | No | Yes |
| Seatback protection | Sold separately | Included |
| What we paid | $240 + tax for front and rear liners, plus $220 + tax for the trunk mat and rear seatback liners (about $460 + tax) | Far less: over $100 off with code PLUGIN35, for all 12 pieces |
Where to buy and what it costs
We bought the Star Trails carpet 9+3 set direct from 3W. Code PLUGIN35 takes 35% off at checkout; that’s the code we used ourselves. 3W also sells the same set on Amazon (sold by 3W) if you’d rather use Prime shipping, without the code.
Buy direct from 3W (code PLUGIN35) →See this set on Amazon
Make sure you pick the 2025–2027 (Juniper) version. The earlier 2020–2024 Model Y uses a different floor, and 3W sells a separate set for it; see our 2020–2024 floor mat guide.
Who should buy this set
- Families with kids in the second row. The one-piece rear mat handles dirty shoes and crumbs, and the under-seat extensions up front add storage the Tesla mats don’t have.
- Anyone who wants carpet looks with rubber protection. The inserts are the only reason to pay more than the all-rubber set.
- Snow and beach households. The raised edges and the sub-trunk liner are built for wet, sandy, salty gear.
If you only want front and rear mats and don’t care about carpet, 3W’s smaller all-weather sets cost less. Our floor mats guide compares the options.
FAQ
Do the 3W mats fit the 2026 Model Y Premium?
Yes. Ours is a 2026 Model Y Premium and every piece, including the frunk and sub-trunk liners, fit without trimming.
Do the carpet inserts slide?
No. The round clips lock each insert into its tray, and the tray’s lip keeps the insert from creeping.
Is there a smell?
None out of the box, and none since.
Does the PLUGIN35 code work on the whole set?
It worked on our 9+3 order and took 35% off the list price. Codes can change, so check the total at checkout.



